Predicting the demise of anything can often lead to unexpected consequences. Similarly, clinging to outdated concepts after they have been disrupted can also backfire. A notable example of this occurred in February 1995, when Newsweek published a piece by astronomer Clifford Stoll, who dismissed the potential of the internet, proclaiming it would never replace traditional media or improve government. Fast forward to today, and it’s easy to view Stoll’s predictions as shortsighted. However, he pointed to an essential truth: the internet can often resemble a vast “wasteland of unfiltered data,” with the value of human interaction diminished.
This tension between plot and story is significant in times of innovation. Marshall McLuhan introduced the concept of the “rear-view mirror,” suggesting that we tend to perceive the present through the lens of our recent past, often leading to misunderstanding the future. This implies that while we may misinterpret future events, we can still grasp the underlying narrative.
The story of Blockbuster and Netflix exemplifies this point. Blockbuster wasn’t blind to the changes in consumer preferences, but its legacy systems and shareholder pressures slowed its response to the inevitable streaming shift. Understanding the deeper story rather than just the surface events is crucial for marketers today as they navigate transformation amidst digital disruption.
Current challenges for marketers include determining the impact of AI on content creation and figuring out the future of formats like PDFs and websites in an AI-driven landscape. Harvard’s Theodore Levitt’s “total product” concept provides a valuable perspective. He argues that consumers choose based on the entire experience rather than just product features.
Marketers must pivot away from traditional formats that may no longer serve audiences effectively. Instead of discarding established formats entirely, they should adapt them to meet modern expectations. For instance, integrating PDFs within content hubs can cater to various audience needs, and evolving websites into more engaging platforms can enhance customer interaction.
Marketers are at a crossroads, just as Stoll was in 1995. They must focus on the unfolding story and not get lost in predicting specific events. By learning from the past, they can find clarity amidst uncertainty, preparing for the future’s unknowns.
It’s crucial to remember that though we may find ourselves moving into the future backward, our understanding of past narratives can guide the way forward. Ultimately, as marketers, it’s about crafting and sharing the story effectively.
—
